15 November 2023

Two weeks into retirement, I am back at work, albeit only for two mornings from home (i.e. less pay, two week notice period). It's a bit of an in-between feeling. I am collecting ideas, read through a couple of requests for volunteering (they have been coming for weeks). The spectre of yet another surgery is looming on the far horizon but first more tests which are scheduled for January and February. This means I cannot really commit myself to anything new. So I go for long walks, cycle along the river, watch R dig up the roots from the almond tree that had to be removed and just wait. Made the mistake to look up the surgery procedures and was sent back into my own personal trauma from many years back. 

Which I have pondered during my walks in the autumnal forest, telling myself the whole story again and again. And one of these days, I will need to write it down.

Here we have a glorious young beech tree, aglow in the midday sun, now that the tall trees, having already shed their leaves, allow the sunlight through. 

The Roman historian Tacitus, in the years around 120 AD wrote a lengthy treatise (Germania, which every poor suffering middle school pupil who for regretful reasons opted for Latin as foreign language requirement had to translate) on the German peoples - yes plural, there were many different tribes around at the time- , their characteristics, customs, lifestyle and so on. He wrote at length how these strange blue-eyed, fair-haired tribal warriors saw forests as their sanctuaries, places of worship and home. A lot has been made of this over the years, poems were written, songs composed, lots of glorification and so on. All good, lots of kitsch, yes, but the romantic forest longing is something I would describe as truly German.

But here it is. The nazis knew a thing or two about symbolism and the power of terminology. The German name for beech is Buche and it is one of the most common trees in Germany. They are beautiful, sturdy trees and most people will recognise them. A forest of beech trees is a Buchenwald. But there is only one Buchenwald now and it is not a forest. It was one of the largest concentration camps on German soil. The German name for birch tree is Birke, another much loved tree in Germany. The German word for a meadow surrounded by birch trees is Birkenau, also known as Auschwitz-Birkenau, the largest German extermination camp. At least one million Jews were killed there.

Walking through a German forest is a history lesson whether I like it or not. 

Last Friday, as we have done irregularly in previous years, we attended the Kristallnacht memorial ceremony. Usually, this is a short ceremony by the river near the remains of the original synagogue, now a monument, but this time, it was held inside the opera house with a large police presence, security cameras and all bags were checked, long queues, many people.

A former colleague and active member of the local synagogue walked up to me. I was lost for words but it turned out they wanted someone to listen, so I did. This is what they asked me and I paraphrase.

What do you think happens after a ceasefire in Gaza? That is assuming that Hamas actually agrees to one. Hamas has publicly stated that its strategic goal is to continue the war until all Jews are annihilated. So, who will sit down and talk to them? How?

People who live comfortable lives come up with irresponsible political agitation, loaded with huge moral pathos. Who would not be against the bombing of cities? No sensible person, of course. But if you ask about context and consequences, silence. Did people march in the streets of the West demanding ceasefire when Putin attacked Ukraine? When over 190,000 Ukrainian children (still counting) were abducted by Russian forces? 

That is why it is negligent, cheap and dishonest to simply put forward abstract demands (often in the guise of left-wing radicalism or Christian loyalty to principles or similar) instead of embedding them in a coherent political strategy and then thinking it through to the end.

I wish I was Irish or Danish or of any other nationality that would allow me to simply express sympathy.

13 comments:

Boud said...

Yes, sympathy to all the fear and suffering your colleague expressed. And yes, people did march, in great numbers to demand Putin leave Ukraine. Gaza is like a Gordian knot of warring needs and fears. Civilians on both sides fearing being wiped out. It's beyond sad.

am said...

Walking through the cedar forests here in coastal Washington State is a history lesson, too. This is the ancestral land of the Coast Salish people who have survived against all odds, many of whom still struggle on a daily basis.

Your former colleague's questions are sobering. In an article I read in The Forward, questions were asked in an attempt to find a way to talk constructively about the war and this was the conclusion:

It’s not the past that haunts Israelis and Palestinians; it’s the future.

Those two people, fated to share the same plot of land, are facing the abyss. No matter whose narrative is correct, no matter what happened in 1917, or 1948, or 1967, or 2023, if they can’t come to an agreement about the future, they are doomed.

My thoughts keep returning to the words of an old friend of mine who is a secular Sephardic Jew, her family having lived in the United States for several generations now.

Both sides are right and both sides are wrong.

Long walks in the woods are something I can't do without, especially recently. The young beech tree is sublime.

Colette said...

I think you are wonderful. Truly.

Anonymous said...

I don't read the news at all anymore. All I can think of these days is that humans made up stories about god and religion, about land and boundaries a long, long time ago... and then have spent the thousands of years that follow killing each over it. I so wish things were different, but my dreams have faded. (NewRobin13)

Pixie said...

What AM said, both sides are right and both sides are wrong. Religion is an excuse human beings use, to kill one another.
Crying does help me as well. Yesterday, this whole week has been awful. Not enought nurses, too many patients and then yesterday a gentleman had a terrible allergic reaction to the CT contrast, so we had to code him. Fortunately he recovered and was able to go home but we've had other patients that have not been so fortunate. The week, the world, is too much for me right now. I'm going to put my head down, walk the dogs and bake Christmas cookies.
Take care Sabine.

Steve Reed said...

Isn't it terrible that such beautiful words, for beautiful places, have been hijacked by history and turned evil?

I try to avoid saying much about Israel or Gaza, because it's such a toxic subject and any statement invites fury. But I will say that I've been surprised at the scale of the marches for the Palestinians, and how readily people seem to have set aside the atrocities that launched this bombardment. (And yes, I realize there's been longstanding oppression that led to those atrocities -- the spiral goes back and back and back.)

Roderick Robinson said...

"This means I cannot really commit myself to anything new."

You too! One unspoken side-effect of chronic illness is that it inhibits planning ventures, especially those where large amounts may be spent.

A week ago I received an exquisite (both in subject matter and in expression) communication from the NHS. So exquisite that I scanned it and posted the image on Tone Deaf. But immediately I was into problem land. Would it be possible to start organising a villa rental in France for mid-August, two-thirds of a year away. A project where even the deposit represents a sizeable sum. Things could change.

I need the "fix" France represents. The curative effects of language it provides. The UK is presently unbearable. France has its faults but they're not embedded in my noggin. Dare I book? Might the money be wasted? Organisms and uncertainty.

ellen abbott said...

Israel plays the victim, and they have been victims for thousands of years no denying, but Israel is an oppressor, it is an apartheid state. it has murdered Palestinians since 1947. it has confiscated land and houses, evicting people who have lived there for generations so settlers can move into homes, they send the army in the middle of the night to roust families, toss or burn down their homes, arresting whoever they want and if they resist they kill. there is a whole lot that people don't know about what Israel does and has been doing. that said I do not condone what Hamas has and is doing. neither do I condone what Israel has and is doing. most recently cutting off the power to the hospital and all the babies in the NICU and all the people in the ICU died. they have always controlled the food, water, and power. you resist an order, they kill you. you throw a stone, they kill you. unarmed, young, adult, old. there is no future in Gaza, no jobs, the people are not allowed to prosper. when my jewish kids went to Israel with their jewish youth group and they toured an orthodox neighborhood, they were spit on...by jews. I'm not anti-semitic, obviously, but Israel learned the wrong lesson from the Holocaust. the oppressed have become the oppressor.

Sabine said...

I agree with you Ellen on the analysis of the Israeli politics and military actions past and present. But what set this in motion was an attack by Hamas to convey to Jews that there was no longer a safe space anywhere for them. The Hamas Charter states as their aim the annihilation of Jews and while the attack was extremely violent like an upstaging of the Holocaust Hamas knew that any initial horror would soon be drowned out by criticism of the Israeli military response. Hamas simply had to wait. By now Israel is no longer the victim of an unprecedented vicious and extremely violent attack but rather the notorious troublemaker in the Middle East responsible for endless suffering and misfortune. Exactly what the Nazis always said about the Jews.

Roderick Robinson said...

If we accept the stated aims of the two factions we have a circular argument incapable of resolution. But suppose one side is hiding its real aim. Israel's stated aim is to wipe out Hamas; not everyone believes this is possible. But perhaps the underlying aim is to make life impossible for the Palestinians (not a million miles from what is presently happening); in effect destroying civil life there. Leaving only Hanss. The moral issues then disappear.

ellen abbott said...

you cannot separate the decades of Israel's treatment of the Palestinians from the attack by Hamas. yes, it was a horrid attack by Hamas and they want to kill all the jews but don't you think that's in large part because of the way Israel treats and has treated the Palestinians from the very beginning of the establishment of Israel? there is no safe place for the Palestinians. why is that less important than Israel's safety? you reap what you sow. Fact is, Israel IS responsible for the endless suffering of the Palestinian people. should we not call them out on it, pretend it isn't happening? that's what I mean when I say Israel isn't innocent like the jews of the Holocaust were. and not only is there a rise of anti-semitism, there is also a rise in anti-muslim rhetoric. over here a 7 year old muslim boy was stabbed to death. there will be no peace between two groups that want to annihilate each other especially when religion is involved. which is also why I think religion is inherently evil. I don't have a solution.

Sabine said...

Yes Israel is responsible for Palestinian suffering, never any doubt. But what are the aims of Hamas? Not a free democratic Palestine. Hamas was voted for by a majority in 2006 but when that same year the majority of Palestinian people demanded further and more constructive talks with Israel, Hamas changed course and has ruled autocratic since. Check their charter, they are ISIS, nor equal rights for women, no LGBTQ (both fully legal according to Palestinian law), their leaders live in luxury in Qatar financed by ?? and next door to several ISIS and Taliban henchmen. What has Hamas done since their attack for the Palestinian people? They denied access to their tunnel system for shelter, refused access to their vast fuel depots while Palestinian hospitals ran out of fuel . Hamas is not acting for a free Palestine. Hamas wants another Syria.

ellen abbott said...

I agree with you completely about Hamas. Israel wants to destroy Hamas, as all terrorist organizations should be destroyed, but Israel does not distinguish between Hamas and the Palestinian people. far more Palestinians have been killed by Israel than than Israelis by Hamas, not just in this flair up but every day. jewish settlers in the West Bank immediately started attacking and killing their Palestinian neighbors after Hamas' attack. Israel likes to play the victim while it provokes Hamas like it did when Israeli forces carried out the violent raid at the Al-Aqsa Mosque attacking worshipers and smashing doors and windows. We condemn Hamas for wanting to annihilate Israel, as we should, but where's the condemnation of Israel for wanting to annihilate the Palestinians? Hamas, as you so rightly wrote, doesn't care about the Palestinians. who then is going to stand up for them?