We've been away. It was a good break, great weather, good scenery, mostly no internet, long walks up and down hills and meeting people, old friends, long talks into the night about trying to make sense of the world around us, our place in it and how to handle this whole shit show.
There were castles and forests and streams and valleys and vineyards and old towns and tourists.
There was listening and laughing and also feeling sorry for ourselves and overwhelmed by the tasks at hand but not alone. There were reports on actions and learning and showing up for others, too detailed to share but so very hopeful. That now is the time to escape commodity and replace it with community (paraphrasing Richard Powers) so that our capacity for empathy remains intact.And so today, after the laundry has been done etc. I am so very tired. It's been a lot. But R made apple crumble and there are still some pears and grapes to harvest.
Somewhere someone mentioned something like this as an approach to the endless feed of news and dystopia and schadenfreude and blaming and told-you-so and well, all of social media especially before sleep:
- Check if what you are reading is facilitating more understanding or more confusion.
- Check if it's adding to your awareness or hindering it.
- Check if it's contributing to your knowledge or making you feel more hostile and out of control.
Because the biggest problem is actually a very trivial one: we refuse to believe what we do not want to believe, even when we are confronted with clear warnings.
We have suppressed the fact that each and every one of us bears responsibility. We have lived in a kind of paradise for 20 to 30 years, at least 80 per cent of the population. And we thought it would always be that way. We thought we could buy security with money. Today we are learning that we will have neither endless time nor enough money.
Jeanette Winterson (not sure, thanks for pointing this out, Steve)
You know what to do. Because as a wise woman said ages ago, knowledge is recognizing that a tomato is a fruit, whereas wisdom is knowing not to put tomatoes in a fruit salad.
Codex: Welcome back and couldn't have said it better. Made that choice a few weeks ago.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you had a good break, and that you were able to hash over the world's problems with friends. I try to practice a media diet myself, though I do read some things that challenge my outlook and probably stray into "hostility-making" territory.
ReplyDeleteDo you know the source of the Jeanette Winterson quote? I tried to Google it and the only thing I can find is German politician Norbert Röttgen quoting it in an article in Foreign Affairs. (Which I can't read because I don't have a subscription!) I'm wondering about the context and when Winterson said it.
Thanks for looking into this, Steve. I had copied this quote together with a few other sentences from Winterson's substack (https://jeanettewinterson.substack.com/) some time back but of course cannot find it now. So I put a note in the post and when I find the source, will fill it in. I highly recommend her substack in any case. It's def not from Röttgen, he is a conservative career politician, now retired to the talk show circuit, and this is not his line of thinking.
DeleteYes. Welcome back.
ReplyDeleteAs to the three "Checks"- I find that even when I'm reading what I know to be adding to my understanding, my knowledge in clear and reasoned ways, I still feel hostile. I still feel out of control. Perhaps more so if I really trust the source. I try to only read those things. The truth is absolutely more frightening than anything else could be.
I'm glad you had a good trip away. I'm reading a book that I think you recommended,"The Coast Road", set in Ireland in 1994. I like the book but it's so sad. I didn't realize that divorce was not legal in Ireland until 1995. Nor did I realize that contraception wasn't widely used, at least in this book anyway. Babies trap women in places they don't want to be.
ReplyDeleteSo happy for you to have had that respite, remembering how things really should be, were for a while. that's kind of what I thought. Life after WWII has been peaceful and prosperous, nice but at what expense? We are lulled, deceptively secure.
ReplyDeleteMe? I escape into art or the yard. I only look at news and SM in the morning. I ignore my inbox for days and delete without reading.
I'm very familiar with the tomato quote. My sister used it a lot.
I love that last wise women quote.
ReplyDeleteYes, yes, YES to escaping commodity for community. (I wrote this in my journal. Thank you.)
ReplyDeleteCodex: You might find my post on video games interesting
ReplyDeleteVideo games are like a far away planet, too far for me to get interested. I confess that I never look at any, never played any and nobody in my family does. (Oh wait, does solitaire count?) I did read a few articles on how the gaming crowd is scanned by secret services for recruiting but again, too far a planet.
DeleteCodex: Not what my post is about, but how tech bros imitate games and manipulate.
DeleteI think that's a myth.
Codex: The military or govt sometimes recruits at gaming shows or game related events, but it's out in the open. They need people for cyber crime or drones.
ReplyDeleteCodex: Do you mean job fairs? Various branches including government safety military etc join job fairs forgraduating students. They also put up posters in IT depts at uni of the come join and apply variety. They look for coders not gamers. Games have advertising trailers just like the movies. It's an ad at most.
ReplyDeleteAnyone scanning games for future secret service is a science fiction movie.
Codex: Are you talking about this?
ReplyDeletehttps://www.theguardian.com/technology/2007/oct/18/4
There was a concern that terrorists might use open world games that are international to collide. Gamers are a fairly good honor based community. They quickly call out anyone who behaves inappropriately or cheats.
Have a look at my post. It might surprise you.
A bit like this but it was years ago, a longer article in Harper's Magazine on gamers (computer/video) at a fair in Vegas (?) and the involvement of CIA/FBI in testing responses and actions on a variety of game scenarios. Must have read this 20 years ago. It's not an issue I dwell on, sorry.
ReplyDelete